More Than Our Story

The Truth About Cheat Days

Table of Contents

What’s Up With Cheating?

In today’s fitness culture, many people balance strict dieting with planned flexibility by incorporating cheat meals or refeed days, with some influencers even filming their “cheats.” While occasional “cheating” can help people stick to stricter plans, it can also derail progress if misunderstood or misused. Knowing when and how to use these strategies is essential for long-term success.

Understanding the Differences

  • Cheat Meal: A single indulgent meal within a structured diet
  • Cheat Day: A full day of relaxed or unrestricted eating
  • Refeed Day: A structured caloric intake, primarily from carbohydrates, designed to support metabolism and enhance performance.

Unlike cheat days, refeed days are structured and rooted in nutritional strategy rather than indulgence.

The Pros

Improved Diet Adherence and Sustainability

Strict diets are difficult to maintain long-term. Incorporating flexibility can:

  • Reduce feelings of deprivation
  • Improve consistency
  • Help prevent burnout

According to the Cleveland Clinic, occasional flexibility may make healthy eating patterns easier to sustain.

Psychological Benefits

Planned indulgences can:

  • Reduce cravings
  • Improve mood
  • Prevent binge episodes when controlled

Indulging can be particularly helpful during extended cutting or fat-loss phases.

Hormonal and Metabolic Support

Calorie restriction reduces leptin levels, a hormone that regulates hunger and energy balance. Refeed days – and to a lesser extent, cheat meals – may:

  • Temporarily increase leptin
  • Reduce hunger
  • Support metabolic rate

Research supported by the National Institutes of Health shows that energy balance and hormonal responses play a key role in long-term success in dieting.

Performance and Recovery Enhancement

Higher carbohydrate intake can:

  • Replenish glycogen stores
  • Improve training intensity
  • Support recovery

Higher carbohydrate intake is especially beneficial for athletes with high training volumes.

The Cons

Risk of Overeating

Unstructured eating – especially cheat days – can lead to excessive calorie intake, offsetting a weekly deficit.

Reinforcing Unhealthy Food Relationships

Labeling foods as “cheats” can:

  • Promote guilt
  • Encourage binge-restrict cycles
  • Create an all-or-nothing mindset

Limited Scientific Support for Cheat Days

While refeed days have some evidence supporting their use, cheat days are largely anecdotal and lack strong scientific backing.

Physical Discomfort and Performance Dips

Large, high-fat or high-sugar intakes can cause:

  • Bloating
  • Fatigue
  • Energy crashes

When These Strategies Work Best

Beneficial Sports

Strength & Power Sports

  • Powerlifting
  • Olympic weightlifting
  • Bodybuilding (off-season)

WHY:

  • High caloric demand
  • Supports muscle growth and recovery
  • Helps maintain training intensity

Endurance Sports

  • Marathon running
  • Cycling
  • Triathlon

*Refeed days are especially effective here.

WHY:

  • Replenishes glycogen
  • Supports prolonged performance
  • Aids recovery

When They Can Be a Hindrance

Weight-Class Sports

  • Boxing
  • Wrestling
  • MMA

WHY:

  • Causes rapid weight fluctuations
  • Disrupts weight management strategies

Physique & Competition Prep

  • Bodybuilding (contest prep)
  • Fitness competitions

WHY:

  • Slows fat loss
  • Causes water retention and bloating

Skill-Based / Aesthetic Sports

  • Gymnastics
  • Figure skating
  • Diving

WHY:

  • Energy inconsistency affects performance
  • Digestive discomfort can interfere with training

General Fat Loss

For most individuals, frequent cheat days:

  • Disrupt calorie deficits
  • Reduce consistency
  • Slow progress

What Should Each Approach Look Like?

Ideal Cheat Meal

Goal: Enjoyment without excess

Structure:

  • Lean protein source
  • Moderate carbs
  • Optional treat (controlled portion)
  • Vegetables or a fiber source

CHEAT MEAL PROS:
Provides a single indulgence while maintaining your overall structured diet.

Ideal Cheat Day

Goal: Controlled flexibility, not binging

Structure:

  • 2-3 balanced meals, 1 indulgence
  • Maintain protein intake
  • Avoid constant snacking all day
  • Stay hydrated

CHEAT MEAL PROS:
Prevents excessive spikes in calories while still allowing flexibility.

Ideal Refeed Day

Goal: Performance and metabolic support

Structure:

  • Increase calories by ~20–30%
  • Focus on carbohydrates
  • Keep fats relatively low
  • Maintain consistent protein

REFEED DAY PROS:
They serve a physiological, performance-boosting purpose - deliberate, not indulgent.

Which Approach Is Best?

  • Best for most people: Cheat meals (controlled, sustainable)
  • Best for athletes: Refeed days (structured, performance-driven)
  • Most risky: Cheat days (easy to overdo)

Conclusions

Use cheat meals, cheat days, and refeed days as tools, not necessities. Their effectiveness depends on how you use them and on your goals. For most people, moderation and structure outperform extremes. A well-planned cheat meal or refeed day can support both mental and physical progress, while frequent, unstructured cheat days usually do more harm than good. 

Consistency, rather than perfection or indulgence, is the foundation of lasting fitness results.

SOURCES

Picture of Daniel

Daniel

Daniel is an extremely curious person, a wealth of random knowledge and facts. Extremely passionate about a vast array of interests ranging from health to history, science to athletics, everything culinary and the list goes on. Trust us, you would want to be on his team for Trivial Pursuit. Daniel is also years into his battle with brain cancer. He experienced a seizure while on a Zoom call at work in late 2020 and quite literally, his life changed within minutes. After his operation he started to talk about his story but had always known it was more than just him. From then, More Than Our Story became a PROJECT that has evolved into the starting point it is today.

Related Articles

Fitness

Want to start running? Want to run more? This article will help answers some of your questions, and give you some pointers along the way.

FitnessHealth

Learn the signs and symptoms of overtraining, its health risks, and tips to prevent burnout and improve recovery for long-term progress.

Fitness

Each month we focus on one aspect of the three disciplines, swimming, biking and running, and provide updates on our race season along the way.